Revision history of "Newton's bucket"

This is a list of past revisions of Newton's bucket. Each is preserved exactly as it was last seen, which is to say approximately, and not necessarily here. Diffs are unavailable; the two versions could not be brought to the same location at the same time.

External tools: Find addition/removal · Find which edit moved the page (inconclusive)

• cur | prev February 2019 T. Vogel (talk | contribs) . . (1,390 bytes) (+260) . . (→ Whether it was performed: the man who published it may not have spun one, and the man who answered him proposed a trial nobody has run. the yard entry above remains the only recorded attempt) (current)
• cur | prev August 2013 a professor of mechanics (talk | contribs) . . (1,130 bytes) (−90) . . (rm; it shows the contrary, at some length, and in five steps of which this page carries one)
• cur | prev March 2013 a citer (talk | contribs) . . (1,220 bytes) (+90) . . (→ See also: added to the article on reference frames, where it shows that the frames are interchangeable)
• cur | prev 1949 a logician (talk | contribs) . . (1,130 bytes) (+140) . . (→ Reception: a universe may be given a rotation consistent with the field equations and not with the objection. I offer this as a fact about the equations and not as a view about pails)
• cur | prev 1934 A. Einstein (talk | contribs) . . (990 bytes) (−60) . . (→ Reception: and have now stopped trying. the pail is where it was in 1687 and so am I)
• cur | prev 1918 A. Einstein (talk | contribs) . . (1,050 bytes) (+120) . . (→ Reception: named the objection after him. it guided me and I could not get it into the theory)
• cur | prev 1897 the Mud Geometer (talk | contribs) . . (930 bytes) (+110) . . (I HAVE SPUN A PAYL OF WATER IN THE YARD. IT GOES UP THE SIDES JUST LIKE HE SED. I DID NOT NEED THE HEVENS NOR THE FIVE ARGUEMNTS)
• cur | prev 1883 E. Mach (talk | contribs) . . (820 bytes) (+80) . . (→ Method: increase the sides to several leagues and try it again. or fix the pail and turn the heavens. I do not say what would follow. I say nobody has looked)
• cur | prev 1883 E. Mach (talk | contribs) . . (740 bytes) (+200) . . (→ talk: I grant every stage and refuse the end of it. the sides of that vessel are too thin to matter, and you have shown only that they are)
• cur | prev 1713 I. Newton (talk | contribs) . . (540 bytes) (+290) . . (rv. they do not say it again. each removes a different thing the motion might be a relation to, and I wrote five because four would not do)
• cur | prev 1704 a copyist (talk | contribs) . . (250 bytes) (−290) . . (→ trimmed the first four. the fifth carries the point and the others say it again in other words)
• cur | prev 1687 I. Newton (talk | contribs) . . (540 bytes) (+540) . . (created; five arguments, of which this is the last. taken together they show that motion is not a relation to whatever happens to be standing nearby)

Older revisions exist but have not been located. The page is believed to retain a full history; it is simply not all in one place.