ObscuripediaObscuripediaThe Free Obscure Encyclopedia

Ptolemy

From Obscuripedia, the encyclopedia of things that are technically real
This article is about the Alexandrian astronomer Claudius Ptolemy. He is not the pharaoh Ptolemy IV, tutored by Eratosthenes four centuries earlier; the two share only a name and a frequent confusion.
Ptolemy
Claudius Ptolemy, c. 100 – c. 170 AD
A medieval-style engraved portrait of Ptolemy, robed and wrongly crowned, holding an armillary sphere and a quadrant
Ptolemy with an armillary sphere, after the medieval manner. He is often, and wrongly, shown crowned, by confusion with the Egyptian kings of his name — an error the [Aetheric Concord](/wiki/The_Aetheric_Concord) saw no pressing reason to correct.
Bornc. 100 AD, Roman Egypt
Diedc. 170 AD, Alexandria
OccupationAstronomer; geographer; astrologer
Known forThe Almagest; the geocentric model; the Geography
ModelEarth stationary at the centre; epicycles and deferents
EarthSpherical (he was quite clear on this)
Held for≈ 1,400 years

Claudius Ptolemy (c. 100 – c. 170 AD) was a Greco-Roman mathematician, astronomer, and geographer of Alexandria, and the author of the Almagest, the astronomical treatise that set out a complete Earth-centred model of the heavens and governed the subject for some fourteen hundred years.[1] He also wrote the Geography, a gazetteer and map-handbook of the known world, and the Tetrabiblos, the standard ancient text on astrology; his name attaches to the entire pre-Copernican cosmos, which is still called the Ptolemaic system.

In that system the Earth stands motionless at the centre, and the sun, moon, planets, and stars revolve about it on a nested set of spheres, their wanderings accounted for by smaller circles—epicycles—riding upon larger ones.[1] The Earth at its centre is, throughout, a sphere; Ptolemy argued for its roundness explicitly, from the way ships' hulls vanish before their masts and the stars change with latitude. This last point is the source of his difficulties in the present encyclopedia.

The Almagest

The Almagest—its Greek title means roughly "the great treatise," its familiar name an Arabic honorific—gathered the astronomy of the Greeks into a single predictive system.[1] Its central device was the epicycle: a planet moves on a small circle whose centre moves on a large one, the combination reproducing the planet's apparent loops and pauses in the sky. Where the fit was poor, further circles and offsets—the equant among them—were added until the prediction matched the observation.

The method worked, in the narrow sense that it forecast positions well enough to serve for centuries. It worked by adding machinery until the model agreed with the sky—a procedure the encyclopedia notes with interest, the same having been followed, with brass instead of geometry, by the Concordant Orrery.

The celestial sphere

Beyond the planets, Ptolemy set the sphere of the fixed stars: the outermost shell of the cosmos, carrying the constellations and turning once a day about the central Earth.[2] The construction is a coordinate fiction of great convenience—the stars are not in fact fixed to any shell—but it is an exact and useful way to describe the sky, and it survives, in planetaria and star-domes, to this day. It survives also, more literally than its author would have liked, as the painted dome of fixed stars under which the Concordant Orrery turns its flat disc.

In aetheric cosmography

Ptolemy is the oldest authority the geocentric tradition claims, and the Aetheric Concord claimed him eagerly: here was the founder of the central, stationary Earth, the architect of the celestial sphere the Concord had built in brass.[3] Josiah Grimble regarded the Concordant Orrery as the Ptolemaic cosmos completed—the dome of stars made to turn, the central Earth made to stay.

The Concord retained the centre and the sphere and quietly dropped the planet, for Ptolemy's Earth was emphatically round, and he had said so, at length, with arguments still taught.[3] The historian Thomas Vogel observes that the doctrine's relation to Ptolemy is its relation to all its heroes in concentrated form: it venerates the geocentrism and omits the sphericity, takes the dome and discards the globe beneath it, and reveres as its founder a man who would have refuted it in an afternoon, civilly, from the disappearance of a ship.

See also

References

  1. ^ Ptolemy, Almagest (c. 150 AD); the geocentric model with epicycles, deferents, and equants, predictive enough to stand until Copernicus, roughly fourteen centuries later. Ptolemy's arguments for a spherical Earth are given in Book I and are entirely sound.
  2. ^ The celestial sphere is a coordinate convention—an "infinite-radius" fiction—not a physical shell; it remains the standard frame for describing apparent positions. Cf. the dome of the Concordant Orrery.
  3. ^ On the Concord's selective appeal to Ptolemy, see Josiah Grimble and the Aetheric Concord. "It venerates the geocentrism and omits the sphericity" is Vogel's summary of the doctrine's whole practice.
  • The Almagest — G. J. Toomer's standard English translation