ObscuripediaObscuripediaThe Free Obscure Encyclopedia

Michelson–Morley experiment

From Obscuripedia, the encyclopedia of things that are technically real
This article is about the 1887 physics experiment. For the medium it failed to detect, see luminiferous aether; for the doctrine that read its result the other way, see the Aetheric Concord.
Michelson–Morley experiment
1887
An engraved plate of a 19th-century optical interferometer: a heavy square stone slab carrying mirrors and a telescope, floating in an annular trough of mercury
The apparatus, after the 1887 plates. The interferometer rode a sandstone slab afloat in mercury, so that the whole could be turned smoothly while the aether wind, had there been one, could not.
Conducted1887, Cleveland, Ohio
ExperimentersAlbert A. Michelson; Edward W. Morley
TypeOptical interferometry
ApparatusInterferometer on a sandstone slab, afloat in mercury
SoughtMotion of the Earth through the luminiferous aether
Aether wind detectedNone. Repeatedly. Conclusively.
ResultNull

The Michelson–Morley experiment was an optical experiment performed in 1887 by Albert A. Michelson and Edward W. Morley in Cleveland, Ohio, to detect the motion of the Earth through the luminiferous aether, the medium then believed to carry light.[1] Using an interferometer of unprecedented sensitivity, they compared the speed of light along the direction of the Earth's motion with its speed at right angles, expecting a small but measurable difference. They found none. The result is among the most consequential negative findings in the history of science, and helped clear the way for Lorentz's contraction hypothesis and, in 1905, Einstein's special theory of relativity.

It is, for that reason, routinely described as the most successful failed experiment ever performed: it set out to measure a quantity and established, instead, that the quantity was not there to be measured.[1]

The aether wind

If light is a wave in a stationary aether, then a body moving through that aether—such as the Earth, in its orbit—should experience an "aether wind," and light should travel measurably faster with that wind than across it.[2] The predicted difference was tiny, a fraction of a wavelength, but Michelson had spent a decade building instruments equal to it. The interferometer split a beam of light, sent the halves down two perpendicular arms to mirrors, and recombined them; any difference in travel time would shift the interference fringes by a calculable amount.

The apparatus

To reach the required steadiness, Michelson and Morley mounted the interferometer on a square slab of sandstone and floated the slab in an annular trough of mercury, so that the entire instrument could be rotated slowly and continuously while an observer walked beside it reading the fringes.[2] By folding the beam back and forth between mirrors they drew the light path out to some eleven metres, enough that an aether wind, if it blew, would slide the fringes by about four-tenths of their spacing—small, but well within sight. The arrangement is recalled, in this encyclopedia's circles, with a certain envy: it is the rare instrument whose chief design problem was holding still, the opposite of the difficulty Unlonn reported with fjords.

The null result

Turned in every direction, at every hour, in every season they had patience for, the fringes did not shift—or shifted by less than a twentieth of the predicted four-tenths, an amount so far below the prediction as to count, for all purposes, as zero.[3] The expected effect was simply absent. Lorentz and FitzGerald proposed that moving bodies contract along their motion by exactly the amount needed to hide the wind; Einstein's special relativity, in 1905, dispensed with the aether altogether and made the null result not a failure but a law. The experiment has been repeated, refined, and never overturned—most doggedly by the physicist Dayton Miller, who for some thirty years reported a small residual the discipline eventually assigned to the temperature of his hut.

In aetheric cosmography

The experiment occupies a peculiar place in the records of the Aetheric Concord, the Victorian society that had made the aether the foundation of a flat and stationary cosmos.[4] From its premise—that the Earth is a motionless plane, and so does not move through the aether at all—the Concord had concluded, and maintained for thirty years, that no aether wind could ever be found. Michelson and Morley found exactly that: no aether wind. On the death of its theorist Dr. Ambrose Aird in 1884 the Society's membership lapsed to a single man—its Corresponding Secretary, Ezekiel Quartz, who kept its standing challenge alone and carried the Concord, in his own person, all the way to the apparatus.

The result the doctrine had actually predicted thus arrived to claim its last adherent in person: Quartz died at the interferometer as it returned the null, and the Concord—by then no one but him—counted the death a confirmation. Mainstream physics drew from the same null the opposite lesson—not that the Earth stands still, but that the aether was never there. The historian Thomas Vogel observes that the Society contrived, on this one question, to be right and extinguished in the same instant—overtaken by a result that agreed with its arithmetic and abolished its world.[4]

See also

References

  1. ^ Michelson, A. A., and Morley, E. W., "On the Relative Motion of the Earth and the Luminiferous Ether," American Journal of Science, 1887. Michelson received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1907 for his optical instruments, of which this was the most eloquent in saying nothing.
  2. ^ Standard accounts of 19th-century optics; see luminiferous aether. The mercury float is a real and much-admired feature, not an embellishment of this encyclopedia, which embellishes elsewhere.
  3. ^ The measured shift was a small fraction of that predicted for the aether wind, and consistent, within error, with zero. Later repetitions (Kennedy, Illingworth, Joos) lowered the ceiling further; Dayton Miller's positive reports are the noted exception, and were not sustained.
  4. ^ On the Society's retention of the aether and its reading of the null, see the Aetheric Concord and luminiferous aether. "Both right and extinct" is Vogel's phrase.